Quick Comparison: Kinetics Magnificent vs. Essence Gold Old Buffy

Today just a quick comparion post. In post about Kinetics Magnificent I mentioned, that it reminds me on Essence Gold Old Buffy. I compared them and they do look very similar, but they're not 100 % dupes. They both have dark olive/black base with golden shimmer, although Essence has bigger shimmer, I would say more glitter. They're both easy to apply and are opaque in two coats. 
I can't decide, which one I prefer. Essence was part of Vampire's Love TE, so it's not available anymore. Kinetics is available in Slovenia in Beauty World drugstores (at least in Murska Sobota, I don't know, how is with BW stores in other places). What do you think? Which one do you like the most? Are they close enough for you to have only one of them?

I also updated my iSwap list. I was reoganizing my stash again, because I was doing a list of all polishes, I own, and I decided to give some dupes away. You can find the list here. I don't have photos of the bottles, but if you're not sure, how the polish looks, you can find swatches on my blog or on other blogs. :)